Warm afternoon light in a Charleston bungalow living room with original oak floors, a linen armchair, and windows overlooking a leafy neighborhood garden.

Reading Wagener Terrace's 2026 Sales, From Grove Street To Gordon Street

In mid-September, 161 Grove Street came on the market at $525,000. It's a 1,035-square-foot Wagener Terrace bungalow built in 1942, with two bedrooms and one bath. The listing said it would sell as-is, with known termite damage in the rear bedroom floor and a side wall. It closed on October 30 for $615,000, which is $90,000 over the asking price, or about 17 percent.

That same month, the upper peninsula as a whole was getting a little under 90 cents on the dollar. Both things were true in October, and they point to the main thing this year's sales show. In Wagener Terrace, buyers paid close to $600 a square foot just to be on these streets. The negotiating happened over the renovation premium on top of that.

What The October Report Actually Moved

The Charleston Trident Association of Realtors tracks the neighborhood as part of Area 52, the Upper Charleston Peninsula. Its Local Market Update for October 2026 shows 8 detached homes closing in October, down from 13 in October 2025. The median sale price for October was $782,500, compared with $1,200,000 a year earlier. With only 8 sales, a 34.8 percent drop in the median says more about which houses closed that month than about values. CTAR's footnote makes the same point: small samples can make its percentage changes look extreme.

The year-to-date figures are steadier. From January through October 2026, Area 52 recorded 146 detached closings, up from 128 over the same months of 2025, at a median of $975,950, down from $999,500. Prices held about level through the year.

The figure that did change is how much of the original asking price sellers received. Detached sellers got 89.6 percent of original list price in October 2026, down from 97.2 percent in October 2025. Days on market until sale went from 23 to 74 over the same comparison. Year to date through October, the share was 93.2 percent, compared with 94.2 percent in 2025. Inventory was 40 detached homes in October, down from 61. So the area got more room to negotiate this fall even with fewer homes for sale. The Wagener Terrace sales show which houses that room came from.

Where The Price Cuts Landed

Most of the price cuts in Wagener Terrace this year were on homes that had already been renovated or expanded.

350 Grove Street is a 1,972-square-foot brick bungalow from 1947 that had a permitted renovation in 2022. It was listed at $1,250,000, cut to $1,185,000, and closed at that reduced price on September 15. 208 Gordon Street, a 1947 house of 2,822 square feet with a 2019 addition, was listed at $2,300,000 and sold for $2,100,000. The Post and Courier's real estate transactions column recorded that Gordon Street sale at $2.1 million, among deeds recorded July 20 to 24.

On Ashley Avenue, the listing record for 924 Ashley shows a $1,775,000 price and 188 days on market before the house sold on October 9 for $1,650,000. It's a 1948 house of 2,304 square feet that was described as a comprehensive luxury renovation. 64 Clemson Street, a 1,762-square-foot house from 1947, came down three times, from $980,000 to $925,000 to $900,000, before it sold on August 20 for $800,000.

Three active listings show the same pattern. 274 Grove Street is a renovated 1948 house of 3,238 square feet. It was reduced on October 26 from $3,200,000 to $3,000,000. 28 Gordon Street, described as a fully reimagined 1940s cottage, is listed at $1,775,000 after a $120,000 reduction. 182 Gordon Street, a restored 1940 cottage of 3,543 square feet, is at $2,499,000 after a $76,000 reduction.

The Same Price Per Foot, Termites And All

Price per square foot shows the pattern most clearly. Here are this year's Wagener Terrace closings, worked out from each sale price and the listed square footage.

Address Closed Sq. ft. Sale price Per sq. ft. As described
64 Clemson St Aug. 20, 2026 1,762 $800,000 about $454 Built 1947, three reductions
22 Hester St Aug. 21, 2026 1,388 $650,000 about $468 Built 1940, sold as-is
224 Grove St 2026 1,245 $585,000 about $470 Not described
26 Alberta Ave Oct. 27, 2026 1,448 $780,000 about $539 Not described
161 Grove St Oct. 30, 2026 1,035 $615,000 about $594 Built 1942, as-is, termite damage
350 Grove St Sept. 15, 2026 1,972 $1,185,000 about $601 Built 1947, renovated 2022
130 Darlington Ave Oct. 21, 2026 2,067 $1,395,000 about $675 Built 1938, renovated
924 Ashley Ave Oct. 9, 2026 2,304 $1,650,000 about $716 Built 1948, luxury renovation
208 Gordon St July 2026 2,822 $2,100,000 about $744 Built 1947, 2019 addition

161 Grove and 350 Grove are on the same street, about six weeks apart in closing dates, and within about $7 a square foot of each other. One buyer got a renovation permitted in 2022. The other got a bungalow with termite damage that will need repairs before anything else happens. Per square foot, the two buyers paid almost the same.

On Grove Street this year, an unfinished house and a finished one reached the same per-foot level, and every closed sale above roughly $600 a foot in the table was a renovated or expanded home. Those are also the homes behind this year's reductions.

What The Bungalow Buyer Paid For

The marketing for 161 Grove presented it as a classic Wagener Terrace bungalow on a well-placed lot near the park. The lot is 0.10 acres with a back yard and a shed on a concrete slab with electricity. None of that has to do with the condition of the house. A buyer who paid $90,000 over asking for it was paying for the location, the lot, and the chance to decide the renovation themselves.

The location has more around it every year. Odd Duck Market opened at 637 Rutledge Avenue in July 2026. In Charleston City Paper's coverage of the opening, the owners described Hampton Park and Wagener Terrace as part of their story. Construction on the Lowcountry Lowline began in October 2026. ABC News 4 reported that Phase 1 earthwork is targeted for completion in August 2027 and public access for the beginning of 2028. A buyer on these streets gets Rutledge Avenue and the parks nearby at the same price whether the floors are original or new.

A finished house has a harder sell, because the buyer is paying for someone else's choices. Those include the kitchen layout, the size of the addition, and whether a second story went up. A buyer who agrees with every one of them will pay for the work. Everyone else can wait, and in 2026 the upper peninsula's percent-of-list figures show waiting paid off often enough.

How This Changes An Offer

The 2026 sales point to two different approaches, depending on the house.

On a renovated Wagener Terrace home, the published price is where negotiating starts. This year's reductions on renovated homes ran from about 5 percent at 350 Grove to about 9 percent at 208 Gordon. 64 Clemson came down roughly 18 percent from its first price. A buyer who has compared each renovation against the roughly $600 a foot an unrenovated lot reached on Grove Street can tell a seller which parts of the work they value and which they don't. A renovation with permits on file, like the 2022 work at 350 Grove, gives that conversation something concrete to point to.

On an original-condition cottage near the park, buyers should expect competition, even with known defects. At 161 Grove, the as-is terms and a disclosed termite repair didn't keep the price under asking. The renovation budget comes on top of the purchase price, not out of it. A $615,000 purchase plus a full renovation can put a buyer above what renovated houses nearby are closing for. That's worth pricing out with a contractor before the offer, not after. Our renovations page covers how we approach that math with clients.

For an owner who has held an original Wagener Terrace cottage for years, this year's sales say something about timing. The unrenovated tier is where buyers competed in 2026, and a seller doesn't have to finish a renovation to sell into that demand. Our Wagener Terrace neighborhood page and our earlier comparison of Westside, Hampton Park Terrace and Wagener Terrace cover what the streets around these sales are like day to day.

If you're weighing a Wagener Terrace bungalow against a finished house a few doors down, Anna Gruenloh and The Exchange Co. can walk you through the per-foot comparables, the permit history, and a realistic renovation budget for the specific houses on your list, so your offer reflects what that block is actually trading at. Let's connect.

Work With Anna

Anna prides herself in knowing not only the properties that are available on the market but also the people that live and work in Charleston. Anna has a knack for quickly understanding her clients’ bottom-line needs and guiding them toward the home or investment property that will best suit them.

Follow Me On Instagram